With the U.S. Supreme Court considering a high-profile case involving the prosecution of pregnant substance abusers, policymakers and advocates once again are confronted with the decade-old question of how best to deal with pregnant women who use drugs. This isaccomplished through a statewide OBHP contract withEmory University. We examined only published cases, almost all of which were appellate level decisions. Call 1-800-GEORGIA to verify that a website is an official website of the State of Georgia. The Florida Supreme Court found the medical testimony inadequate to support the trial court's finding that a delivery occurred during the birth process, even if the criminal statute had been applicable.29 In Arms v. State, Arms was also convicted of a drug delivery charge that was overturned by the state supreme court, in part on the grounds that the relevant statute, does not expressly criminalize the passive bodily processes that results in a mother's use of a drug entering her unborn, or newborn child's system.45. 1. In other instances, where medical expertise was referenced, it did not necessarily support the defendants' position. Approximately 700 women in the United States die every year . Eighteen states have laws that say drug use during pregnancy is child abuse. Cocaine use during pregnancy poses severe issues for affected babies both short and long-term. At the present time, the Center for MSACD fulfills several roles in Georgia by sponsoring clinical, prevention, and research programs. Marijuana is the most widely used illegal drug during pregnancy in the U.S., and marijuana use is on the rise among all adult age groups, both sexes, and pregnant women. Marijuana use during and after pregnancy and association of prenatal use on birth outcomes: A population-based study. These same legislators would be hard-pressed to take babies away from mothers who were struggling with medical treatment for hypertension or diabetes. Through these efforts, the Center for MSACD continues to be a valuable resource to individuals, parents, and professionals in Georgia and the Southeast. LEXIS 496 (Tenn. Crim. In the 22 judicial opinions wherein charges were dismissed or convictions overturned, all held that the legislature did not intend to include fetuses in the definition of a child or victim in the relevant statute. Eighteen states have laws that say drug use during pregnancy is child abuse. Kentucky ranks amongst the last in the nation in rates ofchildhood poverty. Most states do not have a law that requires hospitals to test infants and new moms for controlled substances. In 2014, Tennessee became the first (and only) state to pass a law that criminalized drug use during pregnancy, after a district court judge added an additional six years to the prison sentence of a woman who had been involved in a methamphetamine manufacturing operation while pregnant. NAS is a group of withdrawal symptoms that most commonly occurs in newborns after exposure to opioids during pregnancy.If you are pregnant and using opioid pain medications, CDC recommends you talk to your provider before starting or stopping any medications to help you understand all of the risks and make the safest choice for you and your pregnancy. Key takeaways: In some states in the U.S., healthcare providers are required by law to report substance use during pregnancy. MAT is the standard of care for treating people with opioid use disorder especially pregnant women, as quitting opioids too suddenly during pregnancy can result in complications. From 2009 to 2017, the adjusted prevalence of cannabis use in the year before pregnancy increased from 6.8% to 12.5%, and the adjusted prevalence of cannabis use during pregnancy increased from 1.95% to 3.38 percent. Many of the early cases were related to maternal cocaine use, whereas more recent cases tended to involve maternal methamphetamine use. This is a sad situation. Substance use providers that accept Medicaid must give pregnant people priority in accessing services. It found that parents face long wait lists when accessing substance use treatment services and often dont have the means to pay. Facts are largely determined at the trial level. How you know. The Center houses the Emory Neurodevelopmental Exposures Clinic (ENEC), a multidisciplinary clinic dedicated to providing evaluation and intervention services to individuals exposed to substances in pregnancy. 1996), State v. Aiwohi, 123 P.3d 1210 (Haw. My distant cousin is a meth addict. Convictions were upheld only in Alabama and South Carolina, involving a total of four women. Cocaine lingers in a fetus much longer than an adult and often 5-7 days after birth. Many advocates I interviewed in the course of my own research on this subject described the surveillance of pregnancies and non-consensual drug testing performed on pregnant women and their newborns as comparable to stop-and-frisks for young men of color. If a woman is drinking alcohol during pregnancy, it is never too late to stop. Hence, health care providers should select relatively safe drugs. 1 First, they say the developing fetus and newborn will be harmed by prenatal exposure to illicit substances. Between 2002-2003 and 2016-2017, past-month cannabis use increased from 3.4% to 7.0% among pregnant women overall and from 5.7% to 12.1% during the first trimester. You can review and change the way we collect information below. Three courts stated that permitting prosecutions under the contested statute was counterproductive to state policy goals and public health. Neonatal abstinence syndrome . On June 13, 1997, the governor of Tennessee signed House Bill 1413, making it a Class A misdemeanor for child abuse where: (1) a woman consumes alcohol or illegal drugs during pregnancy with knowledge or the reason to know that such consumption may result in harm to her child; and (2) the child is born addicted to alcohol or drugs. Thank you for taking the time to confirm your preferences. Critics argue law will deter women from seeking treatment. These unintended consequences include keeping women from getting the treatment they need and failing to reduce the number of babies addicted to drugs. Maternal Substance Abuse and Child Development Project CPS immediately removed her newborn from her care, largely based on evidence of her opioid use. Will you help us fight back with facts? Several methods of drug testing are efficacious in identifying and monitoring drug use during pregnancy. The Wisconsin law is especially draconian: A woman can be detained against her will for the duration of her pregnancy, her fetus has its own court-appointed lawyer, she can lose custody of her baby after birth and the proceedings are mostly secret. Some research shows that marijuana use during pregnancy is linked to health concerns, including high use of other substances that may impact pregnancy and infant health such as tobacco, and developmental problems in adolescents. Although the legal bases for appellate court decisions varied (see Table 1), the functional outcome was that the charges were dismissed (n = 14) or convictions overturned (n = 11) for 86.2 percent of the women (25/ 29). Katie Jane Fernelius The following information can help you understand [] These cookies allow us to count visits and traffic sources so we can measure and improve the performance of our site. Charges included child endangerment, child abuse, drug delivery, attempted aggravated child abuse, chemical endangerment of a child, child neglect, child mistreatment, homicide, manslaughter, and reckless injury to a child. You can also call 1-800-QUIT-NOW (1-800-784-8669) for free support. A drug possession conviction in Georgia also results in the suspension of your driver's license. 2007), State v. Geiser, 763 N.W.2d 469 (N.D. 2009), Cochran v. Commonwealth, 315 S.W.3d 325 (Ky. 2010), State v. Stegall, 828 N.W.2d 526 (N.D. 2013), Arms v. State, 471 S.W.3d 637 (Ark. Illegal Drug Use and Pregnancy. The Center for MSACD also provides training, workshops, and other informational services concerning prenatal exposure to alcohol, nicotine, illicit drugs, and prescription drugs. Drugs with evidence of fetal harm were widely used. Priority applies to pregnant people referred for treatment. Civil child abuse proceedings are explicitly permitted in 18 states.9 These may lead to termination of parental rights, but not to prison sentences. Significantly higher numbers come from the Centers for Disease Control, which in 2019 reported that some 16% of pregnant women . Before losing contact with her lawyer, M. told me her story via email. State Responses to Substance Abuse Among Pregnant Women, Concerns Mount over Punitive Approaches to Substance Abuse Among Pregnant Women. It's best not to stop abruptly without first seeking medical advice as there may be . MSACD has currently established relationships with at least one community in every region across the state. A November study published in the Journal of the American Medical Association tracked the rise of laws that criminalized taking drugs while pregnant, as well as classifying drug use during pregnancy as child abuse that could result in loss of custody rights or as grounds for a civil commitment. Local, state, and federal government websites often end in .gov. And in order to receive federal child abuse prevention funds, states must require health care providers to notify child protective services when the provider cares for an infant affected by illegal substance use. For more information, see What You Need to Know About Marijuana Use and Pregnancyand The Health Effects of Cannabis and Cannabinoids: The Current State of Evidence and Recommendations for Research (2017). Using illegal or street drugs during pregnancy, including cannabis, ecstasy, cocaine and heroin, can have a potentially serious effect on your unborn baby. Using illegal drugs while pregnant can cause many complications to the baby including brain damage, premature birth, low birth weight and even fetal death. Drug Use by State: Problem Areas. However, in 2015, law enforcement cracked down on drug use during pregnancy. 2007), State v. Hudson, 2007 Tenn. Crim. Federal agencies collaborate with both state and local law enforcement to ensure effective controls over substances that are deemed to be a danger to individuals and to society. So the very condition that Kentucky believes should trigger fast-tracked termination of parental rights is in fact often most effectively treated by close, consistent contact between the mother and newborn. As of 2018, 38 states had . Some research shows that marijuana use during pregnancy is linked to health concerns, including high use of other substances that may impact pregnancy and infant health such as tobacco, and developmental problems in adolescents. Of the 24 judicial opinions, only nine directly referenced medical evidence in the form of medical expert testimony (n = 7), published medical literature (n = 3), or amicus briefs (n = 1). Millions ofparentswho use drugs or have substance use disorders parent their children well. 1992), Johnson v. State, 602 So.2d 1288 (Fla. 1992), State v. Gray, 584 N.E.2d 710 (Ohio 1992), Commonwealth v. Welch, 864 S.W.2d 280, 283 (Ky. 1993), Sheriff, Washoe County, Nevada v. Encoe, 885 P.2d 596 (Nev. 1994), Collins v. State, 890 S.W.2d 893 (Tex. App. For example, pregnant women should drink less than 1 liter (about 3 cans) of diet soda per day. The legislators behind these laws are essentially creating a capital offense for women who give birth despite having used an illegal drug, said Erin Miles Cloud, a senior attorney at the Bronx Defenders Family Defense Practice, who has represented numerous parents facing termination of parental rights proceedings. Linking to a non-federal website does not constitute an endorsement by CDC or any of its employees of the sponsors or the information and products presented on the website. Such inhumane responses to drug use can only exist because they are almost exclusively reserved for poor people and people of color. Kansas and Nebraska have no reporting or testing requirements, the survey says. Comparisons of drug laws to alcohol laws show that the policy trajectories started in opposite directions, but by 2016, the results were the same: Punitive policies were more prevalent than supportive policies across states. Apr 20, 2022, M. Forrest Behne, Craig Waleed, Meghan Peterson, and Lauren Brinkley-Rubinstein Medical and public health experts who are desirous of seeing a greater focus on treatment of substance-abusing pregnant women must stay particularly alert to legislative efforts to expand the legal definition of a child to include fetuses or to define prenatal substance use explicitly as a form of child abuse. To date, the United States Supreme Court has declined to hear cases that raise questions about the constitutionality of such laws. To view abstracts of recent publications in PubMed, see Prevalence and patterns of marijuana use among pregnant and nonpregnant women of reproductive age and Marijuana use during and after pregnancy and association of prenatal use on birth outcomes: A population-based study. We did not examine judicial decisions regarding women who have faced civil child abuse proceedings related to prenatal substance use. Despite progress in the criminal legal system, the drug war remains almost unchallenged in the child protection system, and it is wreaking havoc on families. We do not know the role that medical expertise and testimony played in influencing the judicial outcome at the trial court level. And the scientific literature that suggests that substance use produces social cognitive deficits in parenting is in its infancy and rather underwhelming. Three of the nine mothers arrested that year tested positive for marijuana, and all were held on $100,000 bonds. More concerning, limited evidence suggests that punitive polices may deter women from prenatal care.49,,51 These policies also disproportionately affect minority and poor women.15,52 For example, in one study, black women who tested positive for substances at birth were reported to authorities at about 10 times the rate of white women, despite similar rates of substance use.47 Advocates of the punitive approach assert that drug courts can be used to compel treatment for pregnant women with substance use disorders. Unless otherwise noted, you can republish our stories for free if you follow these rules. The city of Savannah decriminalized the possession of marijuana, effective July 1, 2018. While a robust body of literature supports a causal connection between prenatal exposure to alcohol or tobacco (or lead or poverty for that matter) and negative postnatal health outcomes, thescientific literaturehas not conclusively demonstrated any long-term negative effect of prenatal exposure to opioids. Prosecutors have attempted to rely on a host of criminal laws already on the books to attack prenatal substance use. The groups listed below help people with drug abuse. His girlfriend is also a meth addict. Professional advocacy may best be directed at state legislatures. Neonatal exposure to some drugs during pregnancy can have harmful effects on development and may lead to acute adverse events, including neonatal abstinence syndrome (NAS) and infant mortality. Studieshave found that babies exposed to cocaine in utero are not at greater risk of maltreatment as young children than similarly situated babies. Since the late 1980s, policymakers have debated the question of how society should deal with the problem of substance use during pregnancy. A representative example is State v. Wade, where the court stated, The plain language of the child endangerment statute does not proscribe conduct harmful to fetuses.40 The courts typically made explicit that any ambiguity in the statutes must be construed liberally in favor of the criminal defendant. If you are pregnant or trying to get pregnant and cannot stop drinking, get help. Arizona now has one of the highest foster care placement rates in the nation. The survey also notes that if prenatal drug use is suspected, Illinois, Michigan, Ohio and Wisconsin require health professionals to report it while Indiana requires pregnant women to be tested; Iowa, Minnesota, North Dakota and South Dakota require both. In other words, the key concern in the judicial decisions to date has turned on the courts' interpretation of legislative intent. That said, there are a few things you should know about "drugs-while-pregnant" law across the U.S.: Most states have tried, at one point or another, to prosecute women for drug use during pregnancy. The laws can vary widely from state to state in terms of reporting requirements and consequences of reporting. App.3d 214 (Cal. The court also referred to rulings by appellate courts in other jurisdictions that had held similarly in comparable cases. Georgia regulates the possession of both illegal and prescription drugs. In the medical model, treatment, not punishment, is the remedy to reduce consumption of substances during pregnancy.4 Medical and public health experts are widely opposed to efforts to criminalize substance use by pregnant women.5,,8, Reflecting societal uncertainty about the best approach, legal penalties for substance use during pregnancy because of harm to the fetus or child vary significantly among the states. Otherwise, the law on drug testing newborns varies from state to state. Rapidly detecting fetal exposure to licit and illicit drugs is of considerable medical value. Thus, it is not clear whether racial or economic bias is a factor in these cases. Quitting tobacco can be hard, but it is possible. More mothers may soon know M.s pain. In 2018, an estimated 12% of U.S. residents 18 years or older reported current unhealthy drug use in a national survey. 2006), State v. Wade, 232 S.W.3d 663, 665 (Mo. A mother taking illegal drugs during pregnancy increases her risk for anemia, blood and heart infections, skin infections, hepatitis, and other infectious diseases. State laws now vary considerably in their approach to the problem, reflecting a deep division in public opinion. Drug addiction is a serious problem, especially when the drug addict is pregnant. For the purpose of this review, we identified published legal decisions regarding women criminally charged with a crime against a fetus or child for substance use during pregnancy from appellate level courts. Webster v. Reproductive Health services: the AMA position, Prosecuting pregnant women for drug use during pregnancy: the criminal justice system should step out and the affordable care act should step up, People v. Morabito, 580 N.Y.S.2d 843 (N.Y. City Ct. 1992), Reyes v. Superior Court, 75 Cal. Across the country, hundreds of pregnant women and new mothers have been accused of child abuse or other crimes when they or their newborns tested positive for controlled substances. 19 states have either created or funded drug treatment programs specifically targeted to those who are pregnant, and 17 states and the District of Columbia provide pregnant people with priority access to state-funded drug treatment programs. App. In three of the cases in which medical expert testimony was referenced, the expert testimony was contradictory. 1994), Reinesto v. Superior Court, 894 P.2d 733 (Ariz. Ct. App. Research projects funded by both state and federal agencies continue to examine effects of prenatal exposure on development, evaluate intervention programs, and describe the clinic population using comprehensive databases. The Tips campaign features information about how smoking and secondhand smoking affect specific groups, including pregnant women or women planning to have a baby. Contact your healthcare provider, local Alcoholics Anonymous, or local alcohol treatment center. She had become dependent on opioids, but when she learned she was pregnant, she immediately tried to enroll in a medication assisted treatment (MAT) program. A substantial body of legal literature traces the development of case law related to substance use during pregnancy and problems with criminalization of pregnant women.15,19,,23 In this article, we systematically review published legal cases of women charged with offenses causing harm to their fetus or child as a result of substance use during pregnancy, wherein the trial court decision was appealed. Long-term effects of alcohol include: The baby being born with fetal alcohol syndrome (FAS) having symptoms, such as: Physical and facial abnormalities Learning disabilities, such as not being able to concentrate. After the passage of the 2014 law, this reasoning no longer applied, although it became relevant again with the fetal assault law's expiration in July 2016. At issue is whether the continued drug use of a newborn's mother is tantamount to "child abuse" that would give child protective services workers and law enforcement officers the ability to remove the child from the mother's care - even if the . As of last year, they were still apart, and M. has since lost touch with her lawyer. Four courts noted that allowing a conviction would result in an absurd punishment scheme. To learn more about medication-assisted treatment for opioid use disorder and considerations in pregnancy, visit https://www.samhsa.gov/medication-assisted-treatment. The substances related to the charges included cocaine, heroin, methamphetamine, marijuana, and prescription pills. Criminal Charges for Child Harm from Substance Use in Pregnancy, Journal of the American Academy of Psychiatry and the Law Online, Substance and shadow: women and addiction in the United States, Pregnancy and drug use: the dangerous and unequal use of punitive measures, Fetal protection laws: moral panic and the new constitutional battlefront, Clinical, ethical, and legal considerations in pregnant women with opioid abuse, American Academy of Pediatrics Committee on Substance Abuse, Council on Addiction Psychiatry, American Psychiatric Association, Position statement on the care of pregnant and newly delivered women addicts, ACOG Committee Opinion No 473. How some hospitals are drug testing new mothers without consent, How Alabamas meth lab law is unfairly punishing pregnant women, Mothers: tell us about drug testing at your hospital. Three of the key areas in which they can have an effect are 1) adhering to safe prescribing practices, 2) encouraging healthy behaviors by providing appropriate information and education, and 3) identifying and referring patients already abusing drugs to addiction treatment professionals 13. An official website of the State of Georgia. In the subsequent months, M. saw her son once a week at best. remove barriers to pregnant women with substance use disorders from getting evidence-based treatment that's tailored to their unique needs. MSACD is committed to raising the awareness of thedevastating effects of alcohol and other substances whenused during pregnancy. 24 states and the District of Columbia consider substance use during pregnancy to be child abuse under civil child-welfare statutes, and 3 consider it grounds for civil commitment. One of the authors read six cases in random order, abstracting data into the identified categories of variables to determine the applicability of the a priori coding scheme. Mar 02, 2022. Fentanylis a prescription opioid that can be used to treat severe pain. You will be subject to the destination website's privacy policy when you follow the link. Cookies used to track the effectiveness of CDC public health campaigns through clickthrough data. 10 states prohibit publicly funded drug treatment programs from discriminating against pregnant people. Arizonaslegislation, which became law in April, permits termination of a mothers parental rights, either immediately when her newborn is born or within one year of her newborns birth, depending on how chronic the illicit drug use appears to the court. The National Survey on Drug Use and Health (NSDUH), conducted annually by the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA), provides nationally representative data on the use of tobacco, alcohol, and illicit drugs; substance use disorders; receipt of substance use treatment; mental health issues; and the use of mental health Laws on drug testing of infants and new mothers vary, but the stakes are always high. Y.N., 104 A.3d 244 (N.J. 2014), Late-Onset Sex Offending and the Assessment of Behavioral Variant Frontotemporal Dementia (bvFTD), Factors Associated with Successful Completion of Juvenile Mental Health Court, by The American Academy of Psychiatry and the Law, https://www.guttmacher.org/statecenter/spibs/spib_SADP.pdf/, http://www.tennessean.com/story/opinion/contributors/2014/05/10/tennessee-voices-drug-use-pregnancy-epidemic/8914401/, http://wpde.com/news/videos/regina-mcknight-released-from-prison/, 2017 American Academy of Psychiatry and the Law.